As college application deadlines approach, many high school seniors and their families start asking the same question: Should I apply Early Decision or Early Action?
Applying early can have advantages, but Early Decision and Early Action are very different. Understanding the differences can help you choose the application strategy that makes the most sense for their college goals, academic profile, and family finances.
What is Early Decision?
Early Decision (ED) is a binding college application plan. When you apply Early Decision, you are committing to attend that college if accepted, assuming the financial aid package is affordable.
You can only apply Early Decision to only one college at a time. Most ED deadlines are in early or mid-November, and you would typically receive an admission decision in December.
Because Early Decision is binding, you should apply only if you are certain that the college is your first choice.
Some colleges also offer Early Decision II (ED II), which usually has a January deadline. Like ED I, ED II is binding. If you were rejected from your first ED school, this allows you to try again with another school.
What is Early Action?
Early Action (EA) is non-binding. You apply early and receive an admission decision earlier than you would through Regular Decision, but you do not have to attend the college if you are accepted.
This gives you the opportunity to:
- Apply to multiple colleges
- Receive admission decisions earlier
- Compare financial aid packages
- Compare merit scholarship offers
- Keep their options open until the spring
What Are the Benefits of Applying Early Decision?
Potentially Higher Admission Odds
At some colleges, the Early Decision acceptance rate is higher than the Regular Decision acceptance rate. This is one reason students are attracted to ED.
However, you shouldn’t assume that applying to ED automatically gives you an admissions advantage. Colleges consider many factors, and the ED applicant pool can differ significantly from the Regular Decision pool.
Early decision is not a guarantee of admission.
Demonstrates Strong Interest
Applying ED sends a very strong message to a college that it is your first choice. Because the application is binding, colleges know that students who are admitted are likely to enroll.
Reduces College Application Stress
An Early Decision acceptance can provide tremendous relief during senior year. If you’re accepted in December, you may be able to stop worrying about additional applications and focus on finishing high school strong.
Provides an Early Answer
When applying ED, you usually find out the admission decision months before Regular Decision applicants.
If you already knows where they want to go, having an answer in December can be a major benefit.
Why You Might NOT Want to Apply Early Decision
While Early Decision can be an excellent option for some students, it isn’t right for everyone.
You Want to Compare Financial Aid Offers
This is perhaps the biggest reason to think carefully before applying ED.
With Regular Decision or Early Action, you can compare financial aid and scholarship offers from multiple colleges before deciding where to enroll.
With Early Decision, you are committing to one college if admitted.
Families who are concerned about college costs should use the college’s Net Price Calculator and have a realistic conversation about what you can afford before applying ED.
You Want to Compare Merit Scholarships
If merit scholarships are an important part of your college strategy, Early Decision may not be the best option.
You could potentially receive a significant merit scholarship from another college through Regular Decision, but an ED commitment limits the opportunity to compare those offers.
You Aren’t Completely Sure It’s Your First Choice
If you are still deciding between several colleges, Early Action or Regular Decision may be a better choice.
Your Application Will Be Stronger Later
You may not be ready to submit your best application by November.
Perhaps you want to:
- Improve your senior-year grades
- Take another SAT or ACT
- Strengthen your activities list
- Spend more time on your college essay
- Complete additional supplemental essays
- Research colleges more thoroughly
If waiting will result in a significantly stronger application, applying ED simply because the deadline comes earlier may not be the best strategy.
Is Early Action Better Than Early Decision?
Not necessarily—but Early Action can provide more flexibility.
If you’re ready to apply early, EA can be an excellent strategy. You can potentially receive early admission decisions without committing to a college.
Early Action may be particularly appealing if you want to:
- Know where you stand earlier
- Apply to several colleges
- Compare financial aid
- Compare merit scholarships
- Keep your options open
Should You Apply Early Decision?
Before applying ED, ask yourself these questions:
Is this truly my first-choice college?
Would I be happy attending if admitted?
Have I researched the college thoroughly?
Am I comfortable with the estimated cost?
Am I willing to give up the ability to compare financial aid and scholarship offers?
If the answer to all of these questions is yes, Early Decision may be a good option.
If you’re still unsure, Early Action or Regular Decision may provide the flexibility your family needs.
What Happens if You Are Deferred?
Being deferred from Early Decision or Early Action does not necessarily mean you have been rejected.
When you’re deferred, you’re moved into the Regular Decision applicant pool. The college may consider additional grades, updated information, or the overall applicant pool before making a final decision.
Learn more about what to do if you are deferred.
The Bottom Line: Early Decision vs. Early Action
Choosing an early application plan should be based on more than admission statistics.
Early Decision can be a great choice if you have a clear first-choice college and are comfortable with the financial commitment.
Early Action can be a better choice for you want an early admission decision while maintaining the ability to compare colleges and financial aid offers.
And if you aren’t ready to commit—or your application could benefit from additional time—Regular Decision is still an excellent option.
The goal isn’t simply to get into college as early as possible it’s to find a college that is the right academic, personal, and financial fit for you.
Caring College Consulting 
Leave a comment